Choosing a Building Designer vs Architect for My Granny Flat: What I Learned

·Sy

Guide

When I first decided to build a granny flat, I wasn’t sure where to begin. Should I hire an architect or a building designer? The options were confusing, especially with all the industry jargon and price differences. I want to share my step-by-step experience to help others who are just starting their home-building journey in Australia.

Architect vs Building Designer: Which One Do You Need?

At first, I thought an Architect was the only option, but that quickly changed. Architects are fantastic for large or complex projects because they offer comprehensive control over the entire build, from design to final construction. But they can also be quite pricey.

For my granny flat, which was a relatively small project, I discovered that hiring a Building Designer made much more sense. They specialize in smaller builds and tend to charge less. It felt like the right fit for my budget and project size.

Why I Requested Multiple Design Quotes

I didn’t settle on the first designer I contacted. Instead, I asked several for quotes. Some were incredibly detailed, breaking down every step and cost involved in the design process. Those made me feel confident because I knew exactly what I was paying for.

On the other hand, some just gave a lump sum price with no breakdown. That made me nervous—what if unexpected costs popped up later? If you get a quote like that, be careful. It’s easy to end up in disputes about what’s included or not.

What to Check in Your Design Contract

Another lesson I learned early on was to thoroughly check the design contract. For me, it wasn’t just about the architectural drawings. A good contract should cover the entire “package” — drawings, approvals, and sometimes even help with council applications.

This “one-stop service” approach really saved me a lot of stress later because my designer handled the tricky council paperwork and approvals, which I had no experience with.

CDC or DA+CC: Understanding Approval Options

One confusing part was whether to apply for a Complying Development Certificate (CDC) or go through the Development Application and Construction Certificate (DA+CC) route. The CDC process is faster and simpler, but it only applies to projects that meet certain criteria.

Initially, we planned for DA+CC, assuming CDC wouldn't apply. Later, we discovered my granny flat did qualify for CDC, which saved me time and approval costs.

Tip: Ask your designer early on which approval path is best for your project.

How the Design Process Unfolded for Me

Once I signed the contract, my designer came out to inspect the site. They measured the land, took note of surrounding conditions, and asked detailed questions about what I wanted.

For more complex projects, they recommended a pre-lodgement meeting with the council to understand any restrictions or requirements specific to the land. While my project was straightforward, I still appreciated that proactive approach.

The designer then prepared 2 to 3 initial concept drafts for me to review over about a month. I was able to request up to three rounds of revisions without extra cost, so I took my time tweaking the designs until they felt just right.

Once I approved the concept, the designer moved quickly on to the DA design, which involved coordinating with various consultants like fire engineers and environmental specialists. This stage required several back-and-forths before finalizing the drawings.

My designer also handled the BASIX certificate (for energy compliance) and the environmental impact report—both mandatory parts of the approval process.

Finally, the complete DA application was submitted, and my designer communicated with the council until we got the approval.

Key Lessons I Can Share with You

  • Don’t rush choosing your designer. Get multiple quotes and look for clarity in pricing.

  • Always clarify what services your contract covers—don’t assume drawings only.

  • Understand your approval path (CDC vs DA+CC) early, as it affects costs and timeline.

  • Engage with your designer actively—take advantage of revision rounds to fine-tune the plans.

  • Trust your designer to manage council communications; it’s a major time-saver.


Building a granny flat can seem overwhelming at first, but working with the right professional makes all the difference. If you’re considering your own project and have questions about approvals, design costs, or choosing between a building designer and architect in Australia, feel free to reach out in the comments or explore more posts on this blog!